"He Won't Propose To Me": Woman Tells BF She’d Keep Her Last Name, He Says ‘No’

The symbols around marriage can be a funny thing, mostly old practicalities that many of us still use out of tradition. While rings are a pretty common and visible symbol of matrimony, taking your spouse's surname might still be the most distinctive part of getting married.

Internet celebrity Ethan Payne recently had a heated discussion with his girlfriend Faith Kelly about taking his surname after marriage that caused some debate online. As it turns out, she did not want to use his last name, something he found incomprehensible.
More info: TikTok

Faith Kelly: Ethan says he won't propose to me because I want to be Kelly-Payne.
Ethan Payne: Faith doesn't want to take my name. And that irks me.
- No...
- Yes.
- I want to take your name.
- You don't want to.

- I just want to take mine as well. I'm not saying, no, 'cause otherwise then I would just wouldn't change my name. I'm saying, I want to put mine there, but Kelly-Payne. So if anyone goes, 'Oh, what's your name over there? Oh, Faith Payne.
- So what's the point in this?
- 'Cause I don't want to lose my association with my family.
- You're not.

- Yeah? Okay, great. So let me keep it.
- No.
- It's a personal thing. I've grown up with the name my whole life. I like it. I wanna keep it.
- No. Take it.
- No. You take mine.
- No, take it. Encompass it.

- No, you take mine. Well, then?
- No, that's not what this.. No, no. I am... I just believe that that's how it should be done.
- When you make the first move, when the sun's shinning on my finger, I think about it. Until then, no.
- I'm not having this 'I'll think about it' and then bottling it 50/50. No way. I need 100% die for the badge, ride or die.
- I'll be in there..
- No, I need...

- It'll be so not in it.
- No, I need a full kit.
- I just want to keep it because I like my association with my family.
- No.

If you watched this clip and wondered who exactly these two people are, here is a quick refresher. The man is Ethan Payne, who is part of the Sidemen, a group of, you guessed it, men who have a YouTube channel together. The woman, Faith Kelly, is his girlfriend of two years, with whom he has a daughter.

They have a podcast together, somewhat cleverly named Growing Paynes, after Ethan’s surname, the cause of all this drama. In the clip above, the two were discussing their names post-marriage, and Faith is quite adamant that she doesn’t want to exclusively take his surname, but have a double, hyphenated last name. Ethan is quite resistant to this idea, which ended up sparking considerable debate online.

The traditional method would be for the woman to take the man’s last name, although this has not actually been a “rule” for quite some time, and, indeed, was never the tradition in many places. For example, even in Ancient China, women would not take their husband’s family name, a tradition that is still in effect.

Indeed, the origin of changing one’s name after marriage isn’t even as old as some might make it out to be. It comes from a law passed by King Henry VIII of England in the 16th century, which dictated that new births be recorded under the surname of the father. This created a new norm, which even at the time wasn’t followed to the letter, as some members of the aristocracy would still keep their surname post-marriage.

The practice is still quite common in the English-speaking world, with one study finding that roughly 80% of women change their surname after marriage, while an even larger portion of men retain their surname. Besides the family connection mentioned in the video, there are a number of other reasons why someone might want to keep their surname.

Personal preference is an underrated one, but just as important. In the same way that most people don’t let their spouses dress them, it’s a bit strange and insecure to demand a partner also take on your name. But the more “practical” answer comes from necessity. If a person’s name is attached to their work, it would be somewhat foolish to suddenly change their name.

This applies to creatives, writers, painters, and poets, but also academics, journalists, public figures, and really anyone who has a “brand” that they are interested in maintaining. So alongside her preference to maintain a family connection, Faith Kelly, as an internet personality, has a very legitimate and rational reason to want to keep her surname.

The real issue is why the man in this relationship is so insistent on a very symbolic gesture from his future wife. There is nothing wrong with expressing a preference, but at a certain point, one has to acknowledge that one can’t just make other people do things they don’t want to do, from the color of their socks, to, yes, their literal name.