A 29-year-old Argentine lawyer is facing legal consequences after making a racist gesture toward bar employees.
Agostina Páez was seen in a video recorded at a bar in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, in January mimicking a monkey and making monkey-like sounds as she left the establishment following an alleged confrontation with staff.
After the clip went viral on social media, Páez was arrested and charged with injúria racial (“racial defamation”), a crime that carries prison sentences of up to 15 years.
Highlights
- Agostina Páez, a 29-year-old lawyer from Argentina, could face prison time after making a racist gesture in Brazil.
- The incident took place in mid-January, when Páez and her friends were leaving a bar in Rio de Janeiro.
- Paéz has since apologized for making monkey gestures and sounds at the workers, saying she has “become aware of what racism is.”
Image credits: agostinapaez
Páez has apologized for her actions but claimed she was provoked during a dispute over an overcharged bill.
She said, “It was an emotional reaction. I never imagined the gravity of it all.”
Páez has alleged that waiters at the Ipanema bar behaved aggressively toward her and her friends and made obscene gestures at them as they were walking away.
Image credits: agostinapaez
Security camera footage from the bar appears to show a worker taunting the tourists as they were leaving the bar.
Prosecutor Fabíola Tardin said Páez’s behavior was inexcusable regardless of the circumstances.
“You can't simply waive Brazilian law because she claims she didn't know racism was a crime.”
Image credits: agostinapaez
The lawyer was ordered to remain in Brazil with an ankle monitor. On Tuesday (April 1), she was granted habeas corpus and was allowed to return to Argentina after posting bail equivalent to 60 minimum wages in Brazil, around $20,000, as the legal case continues.
“I had the wrong reaction by letting myself be carried away by anger, and I am paying the consequences for it,” Páez said. “A mistake can define you, but it can also force you to reflect.”
Image credits: agostinapaez
Speaking at the airport after returning to her home country after 70 days, she said, “It feels incredible to be back. I couldn’t wait to arrive. Now I’m at ease. I regret my reaction. Despite the circumstances, I regret it.
“I felt very helpless. I was very sad. I had a hard time. They were very tough months for me, and I still can’t believe I’m here.”
Image credits: clarincom
Páez added that she had apologized to the victims and said her actions stemmed from ignorance about racism.
“This painful experience has helped me become aware, and I hope many others will also become aware and learn more about what racism is.”
Image credits: agostinapaez
Páez’s defense team worked to reduce the charges, and ultimately, the prosecution agreed to lower the possible sentence to two years in prison, a punishment that reportedly allows for substitution with community service and the payment of compensation of approximately $50,000 to each victim.
The potential sentence, reduced because Páez has no criminal record, would eventually be served in Argentina
“The prosecutor understood that the apology meant that Agostina grasped what racism means to Brazil,” stated her lawyer, Carla Junqueira.
Image credits: mdzol
In Argentina, many rallied behind Paéz, claiming she was the victim of excessive legislation and that she was being made a scapegoat in Brazil to deter similar instances of racism in the future.
Lilia Lemoine, an Argentine lawmaker and ally of libertarian President Javier Milei, accused Brazil’s left-wing government of using the incident as a “vendetta.”
Image credits: agostinapaez
Image credits: carlaandradejunqueira
In Brazil, where more than half of the population identifies as Black or mixed race and sl*very was only abolished in 1888, the case is being celebrated as a sign that the legal system is effective and working to finally defend a group that has long been marginalized.
Racism has been classified as a crime in the Brazilian Constitution since 1988, but prosecutions are rare.
After pressure from activists and lawmakers for greater accountability, the country has implemented some of the strictest anti-racism laws in the world.
Páez said she had been provoked by bar staff, who made an obscene gesture at her and her friends
“It is a source of national pride,” prosecutor Tardin said. “Argentines should see it as an inspiration, not as a reason for hatred or resentment.
“Brazil is being portrayed as this authoritarian country,” she added, “when we are simply seeking justice for the harm caused.”
The case is set to reach a conclusion in the coming weeks.
People shared their thoughts on the case and what they consider to be the appropriate sentence for Agostina Páez
