Bored Panda
Close-up of printed green lottery tickets showcasing unbelievable coincidences of winning numbers.

51 Of The Biggest Coincidences Ever Recorded That Are Almost Too Wild To Believe

36
5
Some things in life are easy to explain, but others might make you wonder whether the universe has a secret sense of humor. Imagine running into the same stranger thousands of miles from home, discovering that two complete strangers have lived nearly identical lives, or witnessing two unrelated events line up in a way that seems almost impossible. The odds might be astronomical, but apparently, someone has to beat them.
Recently, people online were invited to share the biggest coincidence in recorded history, and the responses were just very bizarre. Some involve astonishingly precise timing, others feature people and events connected in ways nobody could have predicted, and a few are so strange they might make you question just how random the world really is.

#21

There is a video bouncing around the web these days called “The Strangest Coincidence Ever Recorded?” It tells the story of a ship which sank in the Menai Strait off the coast of Wales on December 5, 1664. All 81 passengers d**d, except one. His name was Hugh Williams. Then on December 5th, 1785 another ship with 60 aboard sank in the Menai Strait. The only survivor – a man named Hugh Williams. In 1820 on December 5th, a third vessel sank in the Menai Strait. All 25 aboard were drowned except, you guessed it, a man named Hugh Williams.
5points

History also offers plenty of examples of coincidences that seem almost too perfectly arranged. Yahoo News highlights several unusual connections involving famous writers, historical figures, and unexpected family ties. Mark Twain, for instance, was born shortly after Halley's Comet appeared in 1835 and reportedly believed his life would be lost when it returned. He passed in April 1910, just one day after the comet reached its closest point to the Sun.

Another striking example involves Morgan Robertson's 1898 novel Futility, or The Wreck of the Titan, which described a supposedly unsinkable passenger liner that struck an iceberg in the North Atlantic in April and lacked sufficient lifeboats. Fourteen years later, the Titanic disaster shared several remarkably similar details

#22

View of the Twin Towers and New York skyline from a boat, hinting at unbelievable coincidences.
There was a tv show called The Lone Gunman. It was a short-lived, comedic spin-off of The X-Files. In the series premier, the plot was about a conspiracy to fly a commercial airliner into the twin towers as a false flag operation. It aired in March 2001.
5points

#23

Lego Batman and Superman toy figures showing unbelievable coincidences in playful moments.
Superman and Batman's mother are both named Martha.
5points

#24

Illuminated Chicago Theater sign at night representing unbelievable coincidences in urban life.
The Great Chicago Fire was the second-worst fire in the U.S. that day. No one remembers Peshtigo, a once-thriving community, because it burned to the ground and was lost forever.

EDIT: As some have noted, there is a town called Peshtigo, WI today. The title character of the TV show Caroline in the City was from there, in fact, and it was an ongoing gag. However, the original town did burn to the ground (ending over 1,000 people) and they rebuilt it a few years later.
5points

Even the construction of the Hoover Dam produced an unusual family connection: the first recorded worker fatality was George Tierney, who drowned on December 20, 1922, while the final recorded construction fatality was his son, Patrick, who died on the exact same date 13 years later. Such stories show why coincidences continue to capture our imagination.

Whether they involve extraordinary timing, unexpected family connections, or events that seem to mirror something written decades earlier, they remind us that reality can sometimes produce parallels that would be difficult to invent.

#25

Lincoln Memorial statue, an example of unbelievable coincidences in history.
Some of my favorites, from my email newsletter which 100,000+ people (and a bunch of redditors) subscribe to:

- Abraham Lincoln created the Secret Service on the day he was fatally shot. At the time, it wasn't charged with protecting the President, but still.
- John Wilkes Booth's brother once saved Lincoln's son's life.
- If your name is Richard Parker, stay the hell away from boats.
- In March of 1951, both the US and UK were introduced to Dennis the Menace comics. But the two Dennis were totally different and their creators didn't know about the other one across the Atlantic.
- The US Civil War started on Wilmer McLean's farm. He left the area shortly thereafter but couldn't avoid the war, as it ended at the home he fled to.
- The code names of the beaches used for the D-Day landings appeared in crossword puzzles before the campaign.

I'll dig through my archives to see if I find any others that I've written up if you're all interested.
5points

#26

Mount Rushmore sculpture carved into the rock, representing historical coincidences.
Thomas Jefferson and John Adams both passed on July 4, 1826, which was the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence.
4points

#27

Gamer with headphones sitting at a computer setup related to unbelievable coincidences in gaming.
Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon takes place during Russia's 2008 invasion of Georgia. The game was released in 2001.
4points

Coincidences may be easier to explain when we look at them through probability and psychology, but that doesn't necessarily make them any less fascinating. Perhaps the most interesting part is that we never really know when an ordinary day might produce a story we'll be telling for the rest of our lives.

Have you ever experienced a coincidence that you struggled to believe was real? Maybe you ran into someone you hadn't seen in decades, discovered an unexpected connection with a complete stranger, or experienced two events lining up in an almost impossible way. What happened, and did you think it was simply chance or something more? Share your stories in the comments!

#28

Violet Jessop

20 September 1911 - Survived the sinking of the RMS Olympic, the largest, most luxurious ocean liner at the time.

14 April 1912 - Survived the sinking of the RMS Titanic, the new largest, most luxurious ocean liner at the time.

21 November 1916 - Survived the sinking of the HMHS Brittianic, the Titanic's sister ship.

This lady had a knack for surviving the sinking of the 3 most famous gigantic luxury ships!
Report
4points

#29

A Malaysia Airlines airplane flying in the sky, showcasing unbelievable coincidences of aviation moments.
MH370 was the 404th plane of it's type to be produced.

And it went missing.
4points

#30

Jet fighters flying in tight formation show unbelievable coincidences of perfect alignment and timing.
Thunderbird 6 and Blue Angel 6 just crashed on the same day.
3points

#31

Hands reaching for a plate of cheeseburgers, presenting unbelievable coincidences in shared meals.
Whattaburger and What-A-Burger were founded in 2 different states within a short amount of time of each other. Both founders were completely unaware of the others existence.
3points

#32

Mongol fleets almost conquered Japan twice in 7 years. They were stopped both times by a typhoon.
2points

#33

Vintage sports card of Bobby Layne holding a football, illustrating unbelievable coincidences in history.
Bobby Layne got traded by the Detroit Lions in 1958. After he got traded, he put a curse on the Lions, saying they wouldn't win for 50 years.

Not only did the Lions finish with the worst winning percentage in the NFL for the next 50 years and never make a championship game, but in 2008, exactly 50 years later, the Lions became the first team in NFL history to go 0-16 in a season. They went winless.

Because of this, in 2009, the Lions had the #1 pick in the NFL Draft. They chose QB Matthew Stafford... who lived on the same street and went to the same high school as Bobby Layne did.
2points

#34

Historical portrait of Archduke Franz Ferdinand wearing military medals, tied to unbelievable coincidences.
Archduke Franz Ferdinand's driver not understanding the change in plans and driving right past Gavrillo Princip after the failed hit attempt that same day.
2points

#35

Movie poster for Dennis the Menace, showcasing unbelievable coincidences in movie history.
That the US and UK version of Dennis the Menace appeared in print on the same day for the first time. (March 17, 1951).
2points

#36

A calendar page showing dates, representing unbelievable coincidences in time.
Charles Darwin and Abraham Lincoln were born on the same day: February 12, 1809.
2points

#37

In 1274 and 1281 the Mongols invaded Japan. Both times a typhoon decided to wreck their stuff.

In both cases, Japanese forces most likely wouldn't have been able to repel the invasion without help from mother nature.
2points

#38

The Big Bopper was not supposed to be on the plane with Buddy Holly. He won the seat from somebody else by flipping a coin for it. Imagine all the things that had to occur, not only in his life but in everyone else's, to arrange it so that on that particular night, the Big Bopper was in a position to live or pass away depending on a flipping coin.
2points

#39

Black and white portrait of Michael Jackson, involved in unbelievable coincidences.
Michael Jackson overslept on the morning of 9/11. He had a meeting in the North Tower that morning.

Edit: OK, whoa. There are so many celebrities involved with 9/11. Hollywood conspiracy?
2points

#40

Calculus was invented completely independently by two comtemporaries: Isaac Newton and Gottfried Liebniz. Science is actually full of coincidences like this; it's as if scientific discovery itself is fated and inevitable and humans are just tools for it.

EDIT: A lot of people have made some really good comments about the 'coincidentiality' of scientific discovery. To sum up; one discovery always rests on many others, many discoveries naturally lead to others, and often a problem has only one basic solution. Thus, 'coincidences' are natural in scientific discovery and are to be expected; they only look like coincidences to the outside observer. This is what I mean by the discoveries being 'fated' and inevitable. If Newton and Leibniz hadn't discovered/invented calculus, someone else would have, because it was a solution to many many scientific problems, and other mathematical discoveries had paved the way for it.
Report
2points
36
5